auditing-access-control

Quick Review

The skill provides a reasonable framework for access control auditing with clear use cases and examples. However, there's ambiguity about implementation: the SKILL.md references an 'access-control-auditor plugin' that isn't clearly defined, while Python scripts exist in the directory that may provide the actual functionality. The description adequately covers trigger phrases and use cases (score: 6), but the task knowledge is moderate (score: 5) because the relationship between the mentioned plugin and the actual scripts is unclear. The structure is acceptable (score: 6) with logical sections, though it could better reference the scripts/ directory contents. Novelty is modest (score: 4) - while access control auditing is valuable, a CLI agent with security tools could perform similar analysis; the skill's value-add over direct tool usage isn't strongly demonstrated. The skill would benefit from clarifying whether it uses the referenced Python scripts or an external plugin, and from demonstrating more complex cross-reference analysis that justifies the abstraction layer.