windsurf-multi-file-editing

Quick Review

The skill provides a decent structural foundation with clear separation of concerns (referencing implementation.md, errors.md, examples.md), earning points for organization. However, it suffers from significant weaknesses: (1) Description coverage is moderate - while it lists trigger phrases and general capabilities, a CLI agent would struggle to understand HOW to invoke Windsurf's multi-file editing features without concrete parameters or command syntax. (2) Task knowledge is weak in SKILL.md itself - the 5-step instruction list lacks any actionable detail, entirely deferring to referenced files. Even accounting for referenced files existing, the overview provides no concrete guidance on tools, APIs, or command structure. (3) Novelty is questionable - multi-file editing is a standard IDE feature, and it's unclear how this skill meaningfully reduces token costs compared to a CLI agent using basic file operations. The skill reads more like wrapper documentation than a value-add capability. The allowed-tools (Read, Write, Edit, Grep, Glob) suggest standard file operations rather than specialized Windsurf integration. Overall, this appears to be an incomplete skill that needs more concrete implementation details and clearer value proposition.